Facebook insult costs N$20 000

07 April 2021 | Justice

Windhoek • [email protected]

A Mariental doctor has won a defamation suit against a man who in 2018 made public claims on Facebook accusing the doctor of manhandling an “old woman”, arrogance and medical negligence.
High Court judge Nate Ndauendapo found in favour of Dr Berit David Platt, and ordered the defendant Arnoldus “Sydney” Apols to cough up N$20 000 in damages. Apols was also labelled as “arrogant” by the judge, who in his judgment dismissed his defence that he had no other options but to post his complaints to Facebook in late 2018.
“Facebook is a powerful tool used by people such as the defendant (Apols) to defame and ruin the reputation of innocent people. The only way for those aggrieved by such malicious and defamatory posts and tweets, is to approach the courts for appropriate relief,” he said in his strongly worded judgment.
The post that is costing Apols N$20 000 was published on 6 November 2018. He admitted he was not present when the incident he described on Facebook occurred and that he described the doctor as arrogant and disrespectful based on what he had heard.
It remains on Facebook, despite the court’s order for the post to be removed and for Apols to publish a public apology on the platform.
By 7 April, a day after the judgment was made public on the online justice platform on Tuesday, the post had been shared more than 120 times, and dozens of comments, including some calling on Apols to physically attack the doctor, remained public.
Platt is the health ministry’s chief medical officer for the Hardap region.
In March 2019, he sued Apols for N$100 000.
The post accused Platt of “insulting an old woman … after you gave an injection which she said it strong and was making her dizzy (sic).”
Apols also wrote that the Mariental GP had ordered security to “push clients out of your practice” and claimed he had “heard about your irrogance (sic) and lack of respect towards your clients.”
Ndauendapo wrote in his judgment that the doctor was able to prove during the trial that Apols knew placing his allegations on Facebook would have an “instantaneous, borderless and far-reaching” impact.
The judge concluded that the continued circulation and visibility of the post caused “immense harm and damage” to the doctor’s reputation, more than two years after its publication.
During the trial, Platt told the court that in the wake of the Facebook post, he noticed a steep decline in the number of patients visiting his practice.
Ndauendapo wrote in his judgment that instead of complaining about an incident he did not personally witness, Apols could have reported the doctor to the Health and Dental Council for misconduct, which he failed to do.
“What is aggravating is the conduct of the defendant (Apols). When he testified, he was arrogant and tried to justify his post by all means. He also testified that he has no intention of removing the post despite summons being issued,” Ndauendapo said.
During the trial, Platt testified that in the wake of the Facebook post, he received threats that he would be attacked with knives. He testified that other medical professionals contacted him after the post was published, expressing concern about what was written.
Platt was represented by Frieda Schulz from Neves Legal Practitioners, while Apols’ legal representative was Tukondjeni Nanhapo of Brockerhoff & Associates.

Similar News


Family’s battle to reunite continues

1 day - 21 April 2021 | Justice

Windhoek • [email protected] Namibian High Commission in Pretoria on Tuesday briefly shut the door to Namibian Phillip Lühl after he tried to submit a formal...

Whistleblower Stefánsson scoops WIN WIN award.

1 day - 21 April 2021 | Justice

This year’s winner of the WIN WIN Gothenburg Sustainability Award is the Icelandic whistleblower Jóhannes Stefánsson, who led the revelation of a widespread corruption scandal...

Family crushed by court ruling on baby girls

3 days ago - 19 April 2021 | Justice

Windhoek • [email protected] what has been described as a judicial cop out, a Namibian High Court judge on Monday refused to set aside the Ministry...

SA minsters urged to help Namibian twins Maya and...

3 weeks ago - 28 March 2021 | Justice

Windhoek • [email protected] South African Democratic Alliance (DA) is pushing South African ministers of immigration and international relations to take a stand against Namibia’s refusal...

Immigration bans baby girls from Namibia

1 month - 21 March 2021 | Justice

JANA-MARI SMITHA Namibian father of three has brought an urgent appeal to the WindhoekHigh Court after immigration authorities effectively declared his newborn twindaughters stateless and...

Security company sued for shooting incident

1 month - 05 March 2021 | Justice

Windhoek • [email protected] High Court judge this week gave the greenlight for a lawsuit to continue in which two shooting victims are suing Shilimela Security...

Bad news for same-sex married couple

1 month - 01 March 2021 | Justice

Windhoek • [email protected] Windhoek High Court judge on Friday handed down a defeat to a foreigner married to a Namibian citizen who wanted to be...

Ombudsman tackles CLS favouritism

1 month - 25 February 2021 | Justice

Windhoek • [email protected] John Walters has launched a legal challenge against a Cabinet decision that he argues is unlawful and prejudiced in favour of Namibia’s...

August 26 embroiled in food fight

1 month - 25 February 2021 | Justice

Windhoek • [email protected] defence ministry and two of its August 26 for-profit companies are suing former Windhoek mayor Matheus Shikongo and his company for breach...

Access to courts enhanced

1 month - 22 February 2021 | Justice

Justice minister Yvonne Dausab tabled the Magistrates’ Courts Amendment Bill in a bid to, among others, increase the monetary jurisdictions of magistrate’s courts last weekDausab...

Latest News

Struggle kids ‘stigmatised’

3 hours ago | Social Issues

Children of the liberation struggle, also known as ‘struggle kids’, feel it is hard for them to secure employment outside government, because there is a...

Central estates agents awarded

3 hours ago | Banking

Aqua Real Estate, Rightmove Properties Windhoek and Arnel Properties were announced as the top three central estate agencies servicing Bank Windhoek.In the category for Residential...

Knight Piésold celebrates a century

3 hours ago | Business

From its humble beginnings in South Africa on 1 April 1921, Knight Piésold has established and grown its local operations within Southern Africa, through its...

Visual arts on a roll!

1 day - 21 April 2021 | Art and Entertainment

The Bank Windhoek Triennial 2020 Awards ceremony and exhibition opening takes place on Thursday (22 April 2021) at 16:00. With 491 submissions received of which...

Family’s battle to reunite continues...

1 day - 21 April 2021 | Justice

Windhoek • [email protected] Namibian High Commission in Pretoria on Tuesday briefly shut the door to Namibian Phillip Lühl after he tried to submit a formal...

Campaigning for counselling

1 day - 21 April 2021 | Crime

Members of Parliament (MPs) have proposed compulsory counselling and psychological support for victims, perpetrators or anyone exposed to gender-based violence to end the cycle of...

Whistleblower Stefánsson scoops WIN WIN...

1 day - 21 April 2021 | Justice

This year’s winner of the WIN WIN Gothenburg Sustainability Award is the Icelandic whistleblower Jóhannes Stefánsson, who led the revelation of a widespread corruption scandal...

Sewing machines, fabric for NCS

1 day - 21 April 2021 | Business

Mulungushi Textiles & Importers recently donated overlock sewing machines and fabrics worth around N$100 000 to the Namibian Correctional Services. The Khomas & Hardap regions...

Is your agent making use...

1 day - 21 April 2021 | Life Style

The way we live and work has been dramatically altered by the pandemic. It follows then that the way people buy and sell houses will...

Load More