Family crushed by court ruling on baby girls

19 April 2021 | Justice

Windhoek • [email protected]

In what has been described as a judicial cop out, a Namibian High Court judge on Monday refused to set aside the Ministry of Home Affairs’ decision to deny issuing travel documents to six-week old twins Maya and Paula Delgado Lühl.
The three-week wait for the judgment ended in shock and devastation for Namibian Phillip Lühl and husband Guillermo Delgado, who had hoped to reunite their family this week.
High court judge Thomas Masuku said the urgent application to bring back the twins was rejected, in part, because it would be “judicial overreach” to intervene with the home affairs ministry’s decision.
He admitted in his full judgment that the decision was made with a “very heavy heart, understanding as I do, that it involves the issue of minor children and what the applicant’s counsel referred to as their possible statelessness.”
Masuku explained that the Ministry of Home Affairs had never received an official application to issue the travel documents, only a letter, and this was at the crux of the matter before the court. “If the court issues an order to compel the Minister, without him having had an opportunity to deal with the application in the normal course, that may be detrimental as the court would issue the order in the dark, without the Minister having brought his mind to bear on the merits of the application. This would certainly result in judicial overreach, which would be a subversion of the doctrine of separation of powers.”
He said the application before him was asking the court to “usurp the functions of the Minister”, in the absence of an official application.
Masuku added that only if there is disgruntlement with the minister’s decision after an official application was finalised, would the court be able to review the decision and set it aside. “That threshold was not reached in this particular matter. I would, for that reason, be loath to interfere at this stage, where there is no application before the Minister, and consequently, no decision made by him on the particular application or that of the legislature.”

Major blow
“It’s of course a major blow and a major disappointment,” Lühl said during a call from South Africa, where he has been since the birth of his twin daughters via surrogacy in March. He said the family will review the full reasons for the judge’s decision before deciding on the way forward.
“In the meantime, it really comes as a shock to many, especially within the larger picture of very harsh resistance to make any progress in terms of equal rights for all,” he added.
Delgado, surrounded by family and friends, said he was deeply saddened by Masuku’s decision. “We were hopeful. What we requested was in the best interests of our children, and it seems that it was not a reasonable request. I am sad and disappointed.”
He said their case had clearly become very sensitive and that the judgment reflected that. “If you think about it, we are not asking for something outrageous; it's a humanitarian request. The fact that this cannot be decided, does not make any sense to me, as a father.”

Overreach questioned
“The judge said he doesn’t want to overreach, but what then do we have courts for? That is precisely what the courts must be. To weigh up the different rights; how fundamental they are. Can they just be thrown out the window because we don’t like the sexual orientation of that couple?” labour and human rights expert Herbert Jauch said after the ruling was handed down.
He added that the judgment’s impact on the rights of the three children of the couple is even more devastating. “There are now three absolutely innocent children who would have had a very comfortable, settled life in Windhoek; their lives all thrown in turmoil.”
Both the twins and their two-year-old toddler brother, all born via the same surrogate, are legally the children of both Delgado and Lühl as per South African birth certificates, where surrogacy is a valid and lawful process subject to court approval.
Jauch added: “I do not understand how a judge can say ‘I don’t want to overreach’. Now who must then adjudicate on a matter like this? It hasn’t done any justice to the family and has not helped clarify this fundamental human rights question.”
Jauch added that the judge’s decision is a deep blow to Namibia’s reputation as a country that protects and upholds the equal rights of all its citizens.

‘Disappointing’
The applicants’ lawyer, Unomwinjo Katjipuka-Sibolile, said the reasoning was “unfortunate.”
She explained that Namibian courts are “the last line of defence if the executive doesn’t uphold your basic constitutional rights. It is the court you turn to. For the court to refuse to act, is very disappointing.”
She underlined that at the time the judgment had not been made public yet, the reasons behind the decision were not yet clear. However, she underlined that at its most basic, the case revolved around the rights of children.
“The bottom line is that it’s in the best interests of the children to be with their family, and the present situation cannot prevail.”
Katjipuka-Sibolile said the judgement is endorsing the Home Affairs’ stance which is keeping the family apart. “The court doesn’t want to overreach, whatever that means. We will have to study the judgment. But the court clearly is satisfied with keeping the status quo: namely a family that is apart.”

Crack
Ndiilo Nthengwe of the Namibia Equal Rights Movement emphasised that the judgment reflects Namibia’s “selective morality issue”. She said the ruling showed that Namibia continues to uphold the moral compasses of a predominately conservative, patriarchal, oppressive and homophobic society.
“We are lagging behind. This case, which has not been seen in any country, has shown the world how we treat LGBTQ families.”
Omar van Reenen, also of the Namibia Equal Rights Movement, said it is “sad that the court hasn’t stood on the right side of history and upheld the constitutional mandate of Article 10 – that every Namibian is equal before the law”.
He added that the best interests of the children, which are supreme to any other interests, were also not upheld.
Despite the turmoil in the aftermath of the ruling, Delgado said he was humbled by the widespread support and solidarity he and his family received from Namibians during this fight.
“That’s in line with my experience of living in Namibia for almost 11 years. People are friendly; they have this humanity that we have seen throughout the years.”

Similar News

 

Trial over police attack on trans Namibian begins

2 days ago - 10 May 2021 | Justice

Windhoek • [email protected] trial in which a transgender Namibian is suing a police officer for N$200 000 for alleged assault starts in the Windhoek High...

Family’s battle to reunite continues

2 weeks ago - 21 April 2021 | Justice

Windhoek • [email protected]ibiansun.comThe Namibian High Commission in Pretoria on Tuesday briefly shut the door to Namibian Phillip Lühl after he tried to submit a formal...

Whistleblower Stefánsson scoops WIN WIN award.

3 weeks ago - 21 April 2021 | Justice

This year’s winner of the WIN WIN Gothenburg Sustainability Award is the Icelandic whistleblower Jóhannes Stefánsson, who led the revelation of a widespread corruption scandal...

Facebook insult costs N$20 000

1 month - 07 April 2021 | Justice

Windhoek • [email protected] Mariental doctor has won a defamation suit against a man who in 2018 made public claims on Facebook accusing the doctor of...

SA minsters urged to help Namibian twins Maya and...

1 month - 28 March 2021 | Justice

Windhoek • [email protected] South African Democratic Alliance (DA) is pushing South African ministers of immigration and international relations to take a stand against Namibia’s refusal...

Immigration bans baby girls from Namibia

1 month - 21 March 2021 | Justice

JANA-MARI SMITHA Namibian father of three has brought an urgent appeal to the WindhoekHigh Court after immigration authorities effectively declared his newborn twindaughters stateless and...

Security company sued for shooting incident

2 months ago - 05 March 2021 | Justice

Windhoek • [email protected] High Court judge this week gave the greenlight for a lawsuit to continue in which two shooting victims are suing Shilimela Security...

Bad news for same-sex married couple

2 months ago - 01 March 2021 | Justice

Windhoek • [email protected] Windhoek High Court judge on Friday handed down a defeat to a foreigner married to a Namibian citizen who wanted to be...

Ombudsman tackles CLS favouritism

2 months ago - 25 February 2021 | Justice

Windhoek • [email protected] John Walters has launched a legal challenge against a Cabinet decision that he argues is unlawful and prejudiced in favour of Namibia’s...

August 26 embroiled in food fight

2 months ago - 25 February 2021 | Justice

Windhoek • [email protected] defence ministry and two of its August 26 for-profit companies are suing former Windhoek mayor Matheus Shikongo and his company for breach...

Latest News

Chill with Windhoek Express

3 hours ago | Art and Entertainment

Recurring events• 07:00 Bio-Markt / Green Market at the Stephanus Church (Dr Kenneth Kaunda Street) in Windhoek until 12:00.• 08:30 The weekly Inspire Market features...

Government in catch 22 on...

3 hours ago | Local News

While acknowledging that the majority of Namibians rely on the national broadcaster for information, Prime Minister Saara Kuugongelwa-Amadhila conceded that government cannot meet its employees’...

Murorua takes over BAN reigns

5 hours ago | Banking

The Bankers Association of Namibia (BAN) announced that Nedbank chief executive Martha Murorua has taken over the reigns as chair from Ester Kali, CEO of...

Bowling on a roll

5 hours ago | Sports

Namibia Bowling Association (NBA) president Michael Wells has expressed his pleasure at the improved performance of players at the recently held Namibia National Bowling Championships.The...

Virtual international training for local...

6 hours ago | Sports

Eight Namibian soccer coaches will take part in an international instructor’s course organised by the German Football Federation and Botswana Football Association to help improve...

Old Mutual under ‘10 strongest...

6 hours ago | Business

The 2021 Brand Finance report has ranked Old Mutual in the top 10 strongest brands, as well as in the top 100 most valuable insurance...

Fire safety measures every homeowner...

17 hours ago | Disasters

The recent blaze that unfolded along the Cape’s iconic Table Mountain was a reminder of the very real threat fire poses to homeowners. It is...

Conservancy feeds their own children

17 hours ago | Society

For a second consecutive year, members of the N≠a Jaqna Conservancy are using part of their income to provide food to all registered schools and...

More support of Nam’s sustainable...

17 hours ago | Infrastructure

Namibia’s finance minister Iipumbu Shiimi and German ambassador Herbert Beck signed an agreement on financial cooperation for loans between the two countries earlier this week.The...

Load More