Family’s fate in court’s hands

26 March 2021 | Local News

Windhoek • [email protected]

The fate of new-born twins Paula and Maya Lühl Delgado who have been prohibited from entering Namibia with their Namibian father, now rests in the hands of Windhoek High Court Judge Thomas Masuku who will deliver judgment on 19 April.
The judgement date means Phillip Lühl and his newborn daughters have to remain in South Africa for at least another 25 days, forcibly separated from their family in Namibia who has been eagerly awaiting their return, including Lühl’s 2-year-old son Yona, his husband Guillermo Delgado and the twins’ grandparents.
Masuku on Thursday presided over the urgent application brought by Lühl, a Namibian citizen, who is asking the court to compel the Ministry Home Affairs to issue travel documents to allow him to bring his daughters home.
Minister of Home Affairs Frans Kapofi has refused to issue travel documents to the twins, saying – in a first for Namibia – that Lühl undergoes a genetic test to prove his biological relationship with his daughters; this even though he and Delgado are identified as the parents of the twins on South African birth certificates.
Masuku acknowledged on several occasions on Thursday that, legal jargon aside, at the heart of the matter before the court is to decide what is in the best interest of the children.
Representing Lühl, Unomwinjo Katjipuka-Sibolile of Nixon Marcus Public Law Office, said the matter before court raises the question of “what kind of society we want to live in and aspire to”.
She argued that while the minister and his officials have denied that their decision was related to the parents’ gender, it was a clear case of discrimination that they justified with their genetic link request.

Strange
Katjipuka-Sibolile underlined that internationally-issued birth certificates have always been accepted by the Ministry of Home Affairs in cases where parents want to obtain travel documents or other immigration documents for their children. “The only reason biology is questioned in this case is because the parents are two men.”
She told the judge that the “strange” arguments made by the Minister of Home Affairs that DNA testing is required, and to ignore the South African birth certificates, was an attempt at hiding the true basis for their conduct and “political manoeuvring”.
She stressed that the rights and welfare of the children, as per the constitution, the child welfare and protection act, and numerous international conventions, should be the primary factor in deciding whether to allow them to come home with their father.
She said the minister and his officials have ignored the consequences of their decision on the wellbeing of the infants. “If he had, he would have understood that regardless of the judgment awaiting in the case of their brother, two children are involved. This requires that he places the children's rights and wellbeing first.”
She said it is unclear what the ministry hoped to achieve by banning the twins; entry into Namibia.
Katjipuka-Sibolile added that if the twins can return home, the issue of their nationality by descent can be clarified later, as the family awaits judgment in a case brought by Lühl and his husband on behalf of their toddler son, who they want to have declared a Namibian by descent.

Technicalities
Government lawyer Jabulani Ncube denied the ministry’s decision constituted discrimination and argued that the ministry was simply following the laws of the country. “The law is the law. We are standing by the law,” he told the court.
He argued that while the best interest of the child was important, “we must look at the laws”. He argued further that a DNA test would be in their best interest “to know who they are”.
He alleged that had Lühl and his husband followed proper channels and launched an application with the ministry, the outcome of the decision could have been different. He failed to explain on what basis.
Ncube argued that while the South African birth certificates identified the parents of the twins, these documents must be considered alongside the circumstances of their birth to a surrogate.
The court will also take into account an affidavit submitted by minister Kapofi, in which he said the ministry had not been provided with “sufficient scientific evidence to show that [Lühl] is the father” of either his older son Yona or the twins.
He said the ministry refused to take the South African birth certificates into account, as Namibian law “requires a mother and a father. This is why a DNA test becomes a prerequisite for the applicant and minor children.”
He argued that this is “not discriminatory per se.”

Ministry of homophobia
A peaceful protest march took place before court proceedings on Thursday, demanding that the Minister of Home affairs allow the twins and their father to return to Namibia. The marchers accused the ministry of discrimination, violation and harassment against the LGBTQ community in Namibia.
“The Namibian Equal Rights Movement was launched on Independence Day. It is sad that we had to launch this movement 31 years after Independence, to still fight for equality in this country,” activist Omar van Reenen said.
The marchers also handed over a petition to the ministry that garnered more than 3 000 signatures and titled ‘LGBTQ Families Belong Together: #BringPaulaAndMayaHome’.
“Now, 31 years after apartheid, we still have ministries that are abusing their power to abuse free love,” van Reenen said.
He described this stance as “pathetic, grotesque and frankly, disgusting”.

Similar News

 

Government in catch 22 on NBC

14 hours ago | Local News

While acknowledging that the majority of Namibians rely on the national broadcaster for information, Prime Minister Saara Kuugongelwa-Amadhila conceded that government cannot meet its employees’...

Home affairs urges Mexican citizenship for Delgado-Lühl twins

1 day - 11 May 2021 | Local News

Windhoek • [email protected] home affairs ministry has issued a brown passport to the 2-year-old son of Phillip Lühl and Guillermo Delgado to allow him to...

Vaccination campaign for inmates begins

1 day - 11 May 2021 | Local News

The Namibian Correctional Service (NCS) on Monday launched its Covid-19 vaccination campaign.Amongst the first people to be vaccinated at the Windhoek Correctional Facility was Commissioner...

Windhoek’s path to economic recovery

1 week ago - 05 May 2021 | Local News

Windhoek • [email protected] Windhoek Economic Recovery Initiative (WERI) was officially presented at the most recent city council meeting.“The initiative aims to promote economic growth and...

Talks on rate discount for the elderly

1 week ago - 05 May 2021 | Local News

The Windhoek Rate Payers Association (WRRA) paid a courtesy call on Windhoek Mayor Dr Job Amupanda last week, where the association called on the City...

Windhoek +30 Declaration adopted

1 week ago - 04 May 2021 | Local News

The Windhoek +30 Declaration was adopted on Monday during a conference held to commemorate the 30th anniversary of the Windhoek Declaration and World Press Freedom...

CoW erven sale in May

2 weeks ago - 28 April 2021 | Local News

Windhoek • [email protected] total of 71 erven in Kleine Kuppe Extension 1 are up for sale for first time buyers only, by means of tender in...

Keeping girls in school – one pad at a...

2 weeks ago - 27 April 2021 | Local News

Windhoek • [email protected] youngster has decided to stand up and fight against girls leaving school due to their menstrualcycle and them not being able to...

Pension on wheels launched

3 weeks ago - 18 April 2021 | Local News

The Government Institutions Pension Fund (GIPF) launched their pension on wheels truck that is a full mobile office, equipped to withstand harsh road conditions. It...

CoW adapting, planning for sustainable future

4 weeks ago - 14 April 2021 | Local News

Windhoek • [email protected] the amount of challenges the City of Windhoek faces, Council has the responsibility to adaptand plan for a more sustainable future.According to...

Latest News

Chill with Windhoek Express

14 hours ago | Art and Entertainment

Recurring events• 07:00 Bio-Markt / Green Market at the Stephanus Church (Dr Kenneth Kaunda Street) in Windhoek until 12:00.• 08:30 The weekly Inspire Market features...

Government in catch 22 on...

14 hours ago | Local News

While acknowledging that the majority of Namibians rely on the national broadcaster for information, Prime Minister Saara Kuugongelwa-Amadhila conceded that government cannot meet its employees’...

Murorua takes over BAN reigns

16 hours ago | Banking

The Bankers Association of Namibia (BAN) announced that Nedbank chief executive Martha Murorua has taken over the reigns as chair from Ester Kali, CEO of...

Bowling on a roll

16 hours ago | Sports

Namibia Bowling Association (NBA) president Michael Wells has expressed his pleasure at the improved performance of players at the recently held Namibia National Bowling Championships.The...

Virtual international training for local...

17 hours ago | Sports

Eight Namibian soccer coaches will take part in an international instructor’s course organised by the German Football Federation and Botswana Football Association to help improve...

Old Mutual under ‘10 strongest...

17 hours ago | Business

The 2021 Brand Finance report has ranked Old Mutual in the top 10 strongest brands, as well as in the top 100 most valuable insurance...

Fire safety measures every homeowner...

1 day - 11 May 2021 | Disasters

The recent blaze that unfolded along the Cape’s iconic Table Mountain was a reminder of the very real threat fire poses to homeowners. It is...

Conservancy feeds their own children

1 day - 11 May 2021 | Society

For a second consecutive year, members of the N≠a Jaqna Conservancy are using part of their income to provide food to all registered schools and...

More support of Nam’s sustainable...

1 day - 11 May 2021 | Infrastructure

Namibia’s finance minister Iipumbu Shiimi and German ambassador Herbert Beck signed an agreement on financial cooperation for loans between the two countries earlier this week.The...

Load More