Family’s future in court’s hands

03 August 2021 | Justice

Windhoek • [email protected]

High Court judge Thomas Masuku will today deliver judgment in a landmark ruling on whether Namibia’s home affairs ministry must grant Namibian citizenship to the two-year old son born via surrogacy to a Namibian citizen.
Yona Delgado Lühl, born in March 2021 via surrogacy to Namibian citizen Phillip Lühl and husband Guillermo Delgado, has been denied citizenship by Namibia’s authorities since his birth more than two years ago.
His twin sisters Maya and Paula also remain stateless since their birth in March this year. Today’s court ruling will determine their chances of being granted citizenship.
The infants were banned from entering Namibia for more than two months by Namibia’s home affairs ministry, which eventually relented in May, issuing once-off entry visas allowing them to travel home.
Namibian authorities have refused to grant the three children citizenship by descent, despite authentic South African birth certificates and South African high court orders identifying the Delgado-Lühl’s as their only, and legitimate, parents.
Unomwinjo Katjipuka-Sibolile yesterday said in essence the case deals with children born to Namibian parents abroad, and raises three important questions for the court to answer.
“Whether the constitution is to be interpreted narrowly, allowing only for ‘traditional families’ with a biological link to the Namibian parent, thus denying adopted children and children born via surrogacy or in-vitro (with both sperm and egg donated), even if born to heterosexual couples, the constitutional right to citizenship.”

Deny a child a parent
Also, whether Namibia’s immigration authorities can dismiss valid South Africa birth documents, and whether the home affairs ministry can legally dispute parentage, despite legal documents attesting otherwise.
In an affidavit submitted to court by then home affairs minister Frans Kapofi, dated February 2020, after Lühl brought a case to compel the ministry to accept his son’s citizenship by descent, the minster dismissed the South African birth certificate as proof of the boy’s legal parentage.
“I deny that the applicant (Lühl) is the father of the child in question as I still require conclusive proof of this allegation.”
He also denied that Lühl was Yona’s parent.
Kapofi argued that in Namibia, children would only be granted citizenship by descent “if he is a child of a Namibian citizen at the time of birth”.

State homophobia
This argument has been disputed by legal experts in Namibia.
In April, the Legal Assistance Centre (LAC) explained “since Namibia lacks a legal framework for surrogacy, heterosexual couples resident in Namibia have similarly gone to South Africa to make surrogacy arrangements – without any difficulties in bringing their children home to Namibia.”
The LAC noted that Namibians have also been granted citizenship to children who were born via artificial insemination, even if both the egg and sperm were donated.
The LAC further pointed out that in cases of adoption, locally or in foreign countries, Namibian citizens have not had to provide proof of a genetic link to be granted citizenship for their children.
Many have pointed out that the attitude of home affairs to accept the Delgado-Lühl family is a homophobic stance.
“If Phillip and Guillermo had been partners of opposite sexes instead of partners of the same sex, no one would ever have questioned the twins’ birth certificate or asked for a DNA test,” the LAC noted.

Exile
The ruling could determine the family’s future, with Lühl earlier this year noting that their worst fear is having to self-exile due to government’s refusal to acknowledge them as a legitimate family unit.
Katjipuka-Sibolile, in arguments submitted to court, said that at the core of the case is the “notion of the inherent dignity and the equal and inalienable rights of all members of the human family”.
She also urged High Court Judge Thomas Masuku to consider the constitutional and human rights of the children.

Similar News

 

Anxiety, hope surrounds landmark same-sex marriage judgment

4 days ago - 17 January 2022 | Justice

Windhoek • [email protected] long legal battle against government by two Namibians and their same-sex foreign born spouses is heading towards a watershed judgment in the...

Pricey justice bars most Namibians from access

1 month - 06 December 2021 | Justice

Windhoek • [email protected] to justice through private lawyers is a pipe dream for a majority of Namibians, with prices for professional legal assistance far exceeding...

Florin in fresh bid for freedom

1 month - 02 December 2021 | Justice

Windhoek • [email protected] hearing to decide whether former chef Thomas Adolf Florin (54) – the man who butchered and cooked the bones of his wife...

Security company owner, supervisor settle with Zimbabwean widow

1 month - 01 December 2021 | Justice

Windhoek • [email protected] Otjiwarongo security company owner and supervisor charged with the murder of a Zimbabwean woodcarver in 2020, agreed settle with the man’s widow...

Lifers make bid for early parole

1 month - 28 November 2021 | Justice

Windhoek • [email protected] men sentenced to ultra-long imprisonments including life, are battling to be released on parole after serving more than half of their jail...

Toddler’s death haunts family suing health ministry

2 months ago - 18 November 2021 | Justice

Windhoek • [email protected] father of 3-year-old Shaziriah Jacinta Mweneni du Plessis who died hours after receiving rabies shots at the Katutura State hospital in March...

Tax payers foot state’s LGBTQ discrimination

2 months ago - 16 November 2021 | Justice

Windhoek • [email protected] Namibia Equal Rights Movement on Monday called on home affairs minister Albert Kawana and government to stop abusing tax payers’ money to...

Police pay for transphobic attack

2 months ago - 14 November 2021 | Justice

Windhoek • [email protected] police officer’s transphobic attack and unlawful arrest of a Namibian transgender woman five years ago, is costing the Namibian police N$50 000....

End of legal battle between CRAN, MTC in sight

2 months ago - 08 November 2021 | Justice

Windhoek • [email protected] Communications Regulatory Authority of Namibia (CRAN) and Mobile Telecommunications Limited (MTC) presented their final oral arguments in the High Court in Windhoek...

Home affairs defends anti-gay stance

2 months ago - 08 November 2021 | Justice

Windhoek • [email protected] Home Affairs ministry has acknowledged that their approach to an application for citizenship by descent for the two-year-old son of a Namibian...

Latest News

Vyf damme kry water

14 hours ago | Environment

Elvira HattinghTeen gistermiddag om 14:50 het die Hardapdam nog sowat 289,3 m³ water per sekonde ingekry, terwyl nog drie ander nasionale damme sedert Maandag ‘n...

Am Weinberg joins Gondwana Collection

16 hours ago | Business

Come 1 February and the Am Weinberg Hotel will join the Gondwana portfolio in a management capacity. According to CEO Gys Joubert of Gondwana Collection...

Cycle lanes progressing well

1 day - 19 January 2022 | Infrastructure

The City of Windhoek in collaboration with the Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit (GIZ Namibia) continue working towards sustainable mobility in the city.Together, the parties...

Good news for Stadio students

1 day - 19 January 2022 | Education

Stadio announced that the Minister of Justice, on recommendation from the Board for Legal Education, has pursuant to Section 5 of the Legal Practitioners Act,...

Here’s looking at 100 days

1 day - 19 January 2022 | Business

Agribank’s new chief executive Dr Raphael Karuaihe revealed his first 100-day plan at the helm of the bank.He made the announcement during his first staff...

Otjomuise flooding: CoW reacts

1 day - 19 January 2022 | Disasters

Windhoek • [email protected] houses on either side of a river running parallel to Istanbul Street in Otjomuise flooded on Sunday afternoon, with many residents involved...

A closer look at Green...

2 days ago - 19 January 2022 | Events

Prof Anicia Peters hosts a public talk on Namibia and Green Energy at the Scientific Society on Thursday, 27 January.The Namibia Green Hydrogen Research Institute...

Klein Mariana ’n baanbreker

2 days ago - 18 January 2022 | Education

Windhoek • [email protected] was sedert 2016 nog altyd deel van die Grobler-gesin se reis. Dit was toe dat hul dogter Mariana gediagnoseer is met die...

Flash floods have residents in...

2 days ago - 18 January 2022 | Local News

Windhoek • [email protected] river that runs parallel to Instanbul Street in Otjomuise flooded numerous shacks on both sides at around 15:00 on Sunday. Storm water...

Load More