Land remains a hot potato

08 October 2020 | Government

Windhoek • [email protected]

The scorecard on how the country has fared in terms of implementing the 40 resolutions taken two years ago at the second national land conference is mixed. Experts warn it is a complex issue that will take time but underline that the unequal distribution of land in Namibia continues to raise hackles and raw emotions.
“The land conference could not resolve the land question and to expect this from a conference would be completely unrealistic,” Professor Henning Melber said.
On the issue of restitution of land, Melber pointed out that fewer than 5 000 predominantly white commercial farmers own 48% of the land in Namibia, while 35% is reserved for communal use and the state holds another 17% of the land.
“There must be an understanding of the fact that land reform is a difficult and costly process. However, this is a necessary process too, for reasons of political and economic stability,” Willem Odendaal, a consultant to the Legal Assistance Centre's Land, Environment and Development Project (LEAD) said recently.
Odendaal cautioned further that a post-mortem of how the implementation of the 40 resolutions taken in 2018 have fared, has to be measured against the backdrop of funding challenges as well as the pandemic.
He added that acquiring land is the easy part and supported by Namibian legislation.
However, land reform “does not end at the redistribution process. Its success depends on whether people can make a living off the land once they have acquired it as well as the support and tenure security they can get afterwards,” Odendaal underlined.

Step in the right direction
Melber and Odendaal agree that although the resolutions were a step in the right direction, and some have already been delivered on, the resolutions tried to accommodate a lot of crosscutting perspectives and could have been more concise and coherent.
Melber says the run-up to the second national land conference was “marred by competing political approaches, which were more divisive than unifying, which damaged the overall general aim”.Yet all was not lost, ass the conflict was a catalyst “that helped to advance matters” on some issues, including ancestral land claims, he said.
Odendaal added that apart from the issue of ancestral lands, other actions have taken place, including the removal of illegal fences in communal areas.
Melber pointed out that some of the resolutions, such as those on foreign land ownership, were violated at the same time they were adopted, such as those concerning foreign-owned land in Namibia.

Hot topics
Experts say efforts to tackle key land issues since Independence were mixed.
Odendaal says although land has been redistributed “it is arguably not enough and it also hasn’t reached enough of its intended target audience, the poor and the landless”.
He added that colonialism’s legacy of land dispossession and discrimination, as well as apartheid, is “still very much in many people’s minds. While some significant land reform has taken place since Independence, many people remain unhappy about what they regard as the slow process of land reform.”
Melber notes that land remains a “hot potato” that government is reluctant to touch. “But by ignoring a problem, it does not vanish.”
He highlighted that the debate over how Namibia’s constitutional principles can be not only an obstacle but also offer a tool, has made progress and offers some useful strategies “that should be applied more vigorously”.
In a paper published in June this year, Odendaal writes that given that ancestral land claims have no statutory basis or case precedent in Namibian law, the Namibian Constitution, international law and comparative case law could in principle provide the necessary legal guidance for ancestral land claims in Namibia.
He wrote that ancestral land claims are not an unfamiliar concept and have an established foundation in both comparative and international law and that ancestral land claims also find favour in the legal pluralistic character of the Namibian Constitution.
“Dismissing ancestral land claims because they raise uneasy political questions should not exclude the possibility that the law, if developed to allow ancestral land claims, could complement and strengthen the existing land reform programme by securing the land rights that so many of Namibia’s minority and marginalised indigenous peoples still do not have.”
Melber cautioned that the issue of land will remain a thorn in the country’s side as long as its distribution remains skewed; a visible reminder of the colonial era and its lasting impact.
“That this perspective allays only to parts of Namibia’s population adds to the complications,” he said.
In a paper published earlier this year, Melber, under the title Righting a Wrong argues that it is "high time to return land to dispossessed communities”. He argues that as a former colonial power "guilty of terrible bloodshed, Germany should contribute to making that happen."

Targets
Odendaal warned that resentment is building on the land reform topic as a result of the perception that “only a few previously disadvantaged people have benefitted from the land reform process” and that people in influential positions have benefitted from acquiring resettlement farms.
“By making the poor and landless less of a priority for resettlement defeats the purpose of government’s land reform policy. Farmworkers should be considered as key beneficiaries in the resettlement process. They have acquired good skills, but they are often left without tenure security when a farm is sold. This seems a waste of experience.”
Moreover, he says the flawed perception that land equals riches must be addressed.
“Poor post-resettlement support in terms of access to loans, training and access to markets remains problematic for many new resettlement and affirmative action farmers. Also, government has not really been able to effectively combine land reform policy with agricultural policy that could provide food security.”
Drought, climate change and other factors are increasingly battering the agricultural sector, and its contribution to the GDP continues to decrease.
“Land reform should be integrated with agricultural growth,” Odendaal said.
Both Melber and Odendaal are positive about the recent integration of agriculture and land reform under one ministry, which could see the realisation of policy changes in the right direction.

Moving forward
Pablo Gilolmo Lobo’s paper titled ‘In the Wake of the Namibian Second National Land Conference’ notes that despite the hefty resolutions, it could be “concluded that the resolutions were vague with regards to the burning land question in Namibia”.
He warned that a solution to the land question could take years or decades “as was the case with the resolutions adopted at the 1991 conference.”
Still, he wrote that the widespread demand for an answer to the land question could mean that eventually “effective and extensive land redistribution will finally take place in one way or another”.
“Land is belonging and symbolises home. It does so in Namibia for different groups of people who occupied and occupy land at different times,” Melber said.
He says that land is crucial to communities robbed of their land as much as for those who now legally occupy the land.
“To reconcile the two perspectives is almost impossible and contributes to the socio-political problems vested in the ownership of land.”
He argues that since many land transactions took place since the original wave of appropriation by German and South African colonisers “those would be the most obvious inroads to find a solution in a retransfer of ownership to those who were forced into reserves and off their land”.

Similar News

 

National census postponed

2 weeks ago - 15 July 2021 | Government

The Namibia Statistics Agency (NSA) announced that the 2021 Population and Housing Census that was scheduled for August this year, has been postponed to August...

Decongestion hoped for at home affairs

2 weeks ago - 13 July 2021 | Government

Windhoek • [email protected] home affairs ministry has asked members of the public that only one person visits their offices when registering a death and that...

Khomas in need of more classrooms

1 month - 01 July 2021 | Government

Learner enrolment in the Khomas region increased from 94 999 in 2020 to 97 176 in 2021, and if the trend continues, enrolment for 2022...

Okahandja municipality fails to balance the books

1 month - 14 June 2021 | Government

Okahandja local authority councillors were bypassed when the municipality presided over transactions amounting to at least N$90 million in 2019, a direct contravention of the...

National documents: Only apply if urgent

1 month - 07 June 2021 | Government

The Ministry of Home Affairs has urged the public to delay application for national documents that are non-urgent to avoid visiting its office as the...

‘Stop with the tenders’ – Amupanda

2 months ago - 23 May 2021 | Government

City of Windhoek (CoW) Mayor, Job Amupanda said the City spends N$20 million on private security company tenders a year – a practice that should...

Gobabis muni in the red

3 months ago - 02 May 2021 | Government

Gobabis mayor Elvire Theron said the town currently owes NamPower N$13 million in arrears.Theron, in a media statement, stated that the arrears inherited by the...

‘Bring a buddy to parly!’

4 months ago - 17 March 2021 | Government

The office of the Speaker and the Namibia Nature Foundation launched the ‘Bring a buddy to parly’ initiative earlier this week, which is aimed at...

On death and taxes

4 months ago - 14 March 2021 | Government

Despite the dire economic situation caused by Covid-19, government plans to honour financial obligations towards creditors, suppliers and employees, as well as statutory obligations including...

Local procurement pushed

4 months ago - 14 March 2021 | Government

Government has in the past three years pumped in N$1 billion into the public procurement process to promote locally registered companies and hopes to continue...

Latest News

ICU bed occupancy reduced by...

7 hours ago | Health

Health minister Kalumbi Shangula said the hospital bed occupancy rate, especially in intensive care units, has significantly improved in most of the regions, following a...

Why appointing a proxy and...

9 hours ago | Opinion

Windhoek • Taswald JulyMost of us have probably faced death and thought about our own mortality more often, and however daunting the prospect may be,...

Ways to renovate without losing...

9 hours ago | Life Style

For many, the history of a home is what makes it appealing.However, as charming as antique archways and brass finishes might be, rusty pipes and...

Lead by example

9 hours ago | Opinion

Windhoek • Ester KaliDuring these trying times, it is important to approach every situation with as much grace, kindness, faith and empathy as possible. Today,...

Book your cancer screening now

9 hours ago | Health

The Cancer Association of Namibia hosts the next Women's Health Community Clinic in Windhoek on Thursday (5 August 2021), when screenings are carried out for...

The perfect San storm

10 hours ago | Social Issues

The year 2021 has not brought any respite to Namibia from the tragedy and hardship that befell the nation through the Covid-19 pandemic. In fact,...

Segura spog met nuwe winkel

11 hours ago | Business

Windhoek • [email protected] Emporium het begin as ’n aanlynwinkel, maar spog nou met ’n splinternuwe instap winkel inKlein Windhoek.Volgens eienaar Marilie van Schalkwyk, wil sy...

Omaheke remains cattle capital

1 day - 01 August 2021 | Agriculture

Omaheke governor Pijoo Nganate said the region continues to be the champion in beef production, with emphasis on breeds that capitalise on maximum output of...

Supreme Court to review 50-year...

3 days ago - 30 July 2021 | Justice

Windhoek • [email protected] man serving a 50-year prison sentence for the panga murders of a Russian couple 13-years ago has been granted leave to appeal...

Load More