Police guilty of beating woman

27 January 2021 | Crime

Windhoek • [email protected]

A high court judge awarded N$10 000 to a woman after he found that she was beaten in the face by a police officer during questioning in late 2017.
The award is a fraction of the N$100 000 lawsuit Penehafo Naholo sued the police for in early 2019.
Naholo accused the police of cruelly handcuffing her, and electrocuting and beating her in the aftermath of an armed robbery at her place of work.
Acting high court judge Collins Parker dismissed four of the five claims Naholo had sued the police for, due to a lack of evidence.
The resulting investigation found that Naholo was a girlfriend of one of the men who participated in the robbery at a gambling house in late 2017. However, she was never arrested or charged in connection with the incident.
Parker’s judgement said her asking for N$100 000 for all five claims meant, equally divided, each claim amounted to N$20 000.

The first claim dismissed by the court related to Neholo’s complaint that she was unlawfully arrested. Judge Parker however outlined that the claim could not be proven, because the plaintiff was never arrested, as she testified in court.
On the issue of unlawful detention, Parker said “not a wraith of evidence” was presented during the trial to prove this allegation. He added that the police acted within their rights to question her as a key witness to the armed robbery, including being the girlfriend of one of the accused robbers.
He rejected the claim that Naholo had been unconventionally handcuffed, repeating the absence of evidence to support this allegation.
On the claim that electric shocks were administered to her wrists during questioning, Parker relied on a doctor’s testimony that when he treated Naholo following the assault, she had not mentioned “such crucial information” of being electrocuted, and had only described the physical assault.

The only claim Parker was satisfied with that withstood the test of the trial, was the beating Naholo in the face.
He said he felt “it is safe and satisfactory to infer that, going upon a mere preponderance of probability, the plaintiff was assaulted on her face by a police official”.
He said the only claim that held water was the beating, an assault that was supported by bruising over her left cheek, but without resulting in any open wounds. “That is not to say that I overlook the fact that any unlawful assault should be condemned.”
He noted that based on the facts of the claims, “I think N$20 000 for the assault is exorbitant. In my judgement, an award of N$10 000 is reasonable and is capable of meeting the justice of the case.”
Parker also decided that each party in the case would pay their own costs, even though Naholo succeeded in only one of the five claims.
He said he took into account that the defendants were from government, and Naholo is an “ordinary, unemployed person who came to court to vindicate her rights. Such conduct by poor, ordinary persons should be encouraged in a constitutional state.”

Similar News


Watch out for scammers, NamPol warns

2 days ago - 17 June 2021 | Crime

Namibian Police Force (NamPol) spokesperson, Deputy Commissioner Kauna Shikwambi, cautioned government employees to be on the alert for a scam operated by people pretending to...

GBV prevention in the spotlight

1 week ago - 10 June 2021 | Crime

The Ministry of Gender Equality, Poverty Eradication and Social Welfare on Wednesday began with three days of training for its male staff members and members...

Police being sued for infant’s death

1 month - 10 May 2021 | Crime

Windhoek • [email protected] bereaved family whose one-month-old son allegedly died in the back of a police van last month as a result of reckless and...

Campaigning for counselling

1 month - 21 April 2021 | Crime

Members of Parliament (MPs) have proposed compulsory counselling and psychological support for victims, perpetrators or anyone exposed to gender-based violence to end the cycle of...

Multi-million mask deal goes sour

1 month - 20 April 2021 | Crime

Windhoek • [email protected] Chinese owned tobacco company are suing to reclaim more than N$6 million they say was lost when a deal to buy 440...

Educate children on their rights - Husselman

2 months ago - 18 April 2021 | Crime

Children’s advocate Ingrid Husselmann said having a good legal framework for child protection is not enough in Namibia and more needs to be done to...

Khomasdal residents view NamPol with suspicion

2 months ago - 23 March 2021 | Crime

Vice chairperson of the Khomasdal Extension 3 neighbourhood watch, Hilma Iita, said residents do not trust the Namibian Police Force (NamPol) anymore, because “some members...

Protest against homophobic domestic violence bill

3 months ago - 17 March 2021 | Crime

Windhoek • [email protected] justice ministry is under pressure to tweak an amended domestic violence bill to ensure protection for all victims of domestic violence despite...

CoTA students protest against harassment

3 months ago - 16 March 2021 | Crime

College of the Arts (CoTA) students in Katutura on Monday held a peaceful protest against alleged sexual harassment of female students by mechanics working at...

Reho school fire being investigated

3 months ago - 14 March 2021 | Crime

NamPol at Rehoboth are investigating the cause of the fire that extensively damaged a block at the Rehoboth High School on Thursday night.In a police...

Latest News

Are you being overcharged?

1 day - 18 June 2021 | Opinion

Windhoek • Marvin DanielsIt’s been more than a year since Namibia reported its first confirmed Covid-19 positive case in March 2020. Since then, the pandemic...

Charcoal activities unleash large-scale bush...

2 days ago - 17 June 2021 | Agriculture

Windhoek • [email protected] bush fires allegedly sparked by charcoal burning operations have razed around 35 000 hectares of grassland to the ground across seven farms...

Beatrice, Christine readying for Tokyo

2 days ago - 17 June 2021 | Sports

Henk Botha, coach of Namibia’s fastest female sprinters Beatrice Masilingi and Christine Mboma, said the athletes are hopeful of reaching their set targets before travelling...

ECDs at schools shut down

2 days ago - 17 June 2021 | Education

The Ministry of Gender Equality, Poverty Eradication and Social Welfare has temporarily closed early childhood development centres (ECDs) operating within formal school premises countrywide, due...

More vaccination, testing centres on...

2 days ago - 17 June 2021 | Health

Khomas governor Laura McLeod-Katjirua said additional vaccination and testing centres would be identified in the region in a bid to bring services closer to the...

Watch out for scammers, NamPol...

2 days ago - 17 June 2021 | Crime

Namibian Police Force (NamPol) spokesperson, Deputy Commissioner Kauna Shikwambi, cautioned government employees to be on the alert for a scam operated by people pretending to...

Melkies tests Tesla in Germany

3 days ago - 16 June 2021 | Business

The founder and owner of LEFA Transportation Services test-drove the future of transportationwhen he cruised around in a Tesla in Germany recently.Melkies Ausiku has long...

Second Online Agriculture Series on...

3 days ago - 16 June 2021 | Agriculture

Bank Windhoek hosts its second Online Agriculture Series on Wednesday and Thursday (23 & 24 June) themed “Innovation and Trends that will shape the future...

NMRC warns against ivermectin use

3 days ago - 16 June 2021 | Health

Namibian Medicines Regulatory Council (NMRC) Registrar, Johannes Gaeseb, said the use of ivermectin in human beings has not yet been registered or granted authorisation in...

Load More