Protest against live animal shipping grows

01 October 2020 | Agriculture

Windhoek • [email protected]

Public opposition continues to grow against a proposed business plan to import as many as 125 000 live farm animals into Namibia for export over thousands of kilometres via sea to the Middle East.
A petition launched last month grew from just 1 000 signatures at the start of September to more than 6 700 signatures by this week.
The petitioners strongly condemn the proposed plan of Tradeport Namibia to import and export up to 70 000 sheep, 50 000 goats and 5 000 cattle along the Trans-Oranje / Kalahari corridor through the ports of Lüderitz or Walvis Bay to the Middle East for fattening and slaughter.
Tradeport Namibia made headlines two years when the company was found to import manganese ore into Lüderitz port without the necessary environmental clearance certificates. Since then they obtained the required paperwork and continue to import and export manganese.
Numerous reports of animal abuse connected with the live shipment industry have emerged in recent years, showing harrowing footage of the suffering the animals endure onboard and prior to being shipped.

‘Please stop’
“Please stop this horrendous live transport of animals,” one protester writes, while another describes the trade as “cruel and sick”.
These outcries are not limited to individuals but reflect growing international research and exposés that prove the trade’s inevitable cost of suffering to the animals. “Every animal welfare group in the world opposes live export by sea because of the inherent animal suffering and risks that can never be overcome,” Dr Chris Brown of the Namibia Chamber of Environment said recently.
So intrinsic and unavoidable are these risks to the trade, that in Australia, government policy stipulates that 1% of every consignment can die during the voyage before a government investigation is triggered. “This equates to thousands of animals dying at sea every year and some millions over the decades that live export has operated from Australia,” Brown said.
Another concern is the environmental damage caused by the live export as ships carrying livestock dump untreated sewage into the ocean, which equates to hundreds of tonnes of sewage per day.
“The ships also dump carcasses of the animals that die onboard into the ocean. The damage on ocean ecosystems cannot be ignored,” Brown added.
Scientists point out that in addition to the cruelty, Namibia would do better economically to process the meat locally.
“In economic terms, the trade does not stack up. The commercial benefits of the live animal export trade are centred on the company seeking to take the animals. It robs the local economy of the value-add of processing the animals within the country,” Brown said.

Tricky
Days after the petition was launched, the agriculture ministry issued a statement, noting that it “does not allow importation and in-transit of livestock and other cloven-hoofed animals from South Africa” due to the ongoing Foot and Mouth Disease (FMD) outbreak there.
Some say the project is dead in the water due to the challenges they will face to obtain the necessary documentation.
Last month Paul Strydom of the Namibian Meat Board pointed out that Botswana has an embargo in place on the export of cattle to both Namibia and South Africa. He added that livestock exports go against the grain of Namibia’s Growth at Home Strategy.
Brown said research has consistently found that live sea exports do not bear any long-term economic benefits for countries.
He added that all Middle East nationals import large amounts of chilled and frozen meat, which “makes more economic sense for the exporting nation to keep jobs in the country and to export the meat instead”.

Legal and political upheaval
Brown also warned that globally, including in Australia, New Zealand, the European Union, Israel and South Africa, the trade is engulfed in legal and political upheaval because it breaches animal welfare legislation. As the global community is informed about the toll of this trade to animals and the environment, it is increasingly seeing countries ban it.
“The Namibian government must be mindful that cruelty in the live export trade has led to media exposé after media exposé in Australia, causing damage to Australia’s reputation. Also, the live export trade is now coming to Namibia because it has been banned or restricted from taking animals from other countries due to cruelty issues.”
Moreover, the operation of the live animal export trade breaches Namibian animal welfare laws and standards, he said.
The animals experience extreme temperatures and long hours of trucking without rest, food or water, which is just the start of a long and arduous journey over thousands of kilometres by sea during which the animals are prevented from being able to lie down due to stocking densities.
The animals are exposed to conditions such as salmonellosis, heat stress, pneumonia, and high mortality rates.
The animals suffer and routinely die on board the vessels from a condition called ‘shy feeding’ or ‘enteritis’. Over weeks onboard the ship, the animals coats become thickly coated with faeces because they are so densely packed, exacerbating the risks of disease, stress and death.

Not on hold
While Tradeport director Monty Ndjavera in early September said he had given instructions to put on hold the environmental clearance application, it remains ongoing.
By last week Vilho Mtuleni of Enviro-Leap consulting said that no formal instructions were received up to date to stop the EIA application process.
Mtuleni said the process will be handled neutrally and objectively and the public will be engaged accordingly as far as the assessment is concerned.

Similar News

 

Thirteen farmers alloted to six farms

2 weeks ago - 05 April 2021 | Agriculture

The Ministry of Agriculture, Water and Land Reform (MAWLR) last week over 13 allotment letters to 13 resettled farmers on six farms located in the...

Aquaponics system launched

2 weeks ago - 31 March 2021 | Agriculture

Windhoek • Claudia ReiterThe Hanns Seidel Foundation and the Finnish embassy yesterday launched the first aquaponics system at the Aris Primary School as part of...

The basics of grazing management

3 weeks ago - 29 March 2021 | Agriculture

Windhoek • Erastus NgarukaThe grazing value and capacity of the land is a factor of certain attributes which includes the soil condition, grass species composition,...

Former public servant pursues full-time farming

3 weeks ago - 23 March 2021 | Agriculture

Hendrik Motinga, Agribank’s mentee and loan beneficiary under the Affirmative Action Loan Scheme, quit his formal job ten years ago as a Labour Inspector to...

Youth learn about cattle judging

1 month - 10 March 2021 | Agriculture

Bank Windhoek and Feedmaster will again offer a nationwide Youth Cattle Judging Course and Competition, aimed at equiping school learners between grade 9 and 11...

Control pests like this

2 months ago - 15 February 2021 | Agriculture

Windhoek • Hanks SaisaiWhether you have a small garden to grow your own produce, or if you’re a large-scale farmer, crop production is an activity...

Roots delivers first apples

2 months ago - 29 January 2021 | Agriculture

A delegation from the Roots Agricultural village at Stampriet recently paid a courtesy visit to Agribank to present and showcase their first harvest from the...

Now is the time to harvest rainwater

2 months ago - 18 January 2021 | Agriculture

The previous and current rainy seasons in Namibia has given a sigh of relief to many farmers and is an indication that the country is...

Bank backing for locust research

4 months ago - 02 December 2020 | Agriculture

FNB Namibia handed over N$100 000 towards the University of Namibia (UNAM) to support their research relating to the outbreak of the locusts in the...

The benefits of mulching

5 months ago - 02 November 2020 | Agriculture

Windhoek • Hanks SaisaiIn arid and semi-arid countries like Namibia where water is a scarce resource, it is always advisable for farmers to engage in...

Latest News

Covid testing capacity increased again

7 hours ago | Health

Together with the University of Namibia and in addition to the initial machine availed at the launch of the lab in August last year, Debmarine...

Revival, Kudos continue their dominance

8 hours ago | Sports

The Central Volleyball Association (CVA) continued with its league games at the University of Namibia (Unam) and the Patrick Iyambo Police College on Saturday.During the...

NGOs plan the way forward

8 hours ago | Society

In partnership with the Bank Windhoek Social Investment Fund and the Lithon Foundation, the Capricorn Foundation recently hosted an online capacity building workshop for NGOs...

Big cheque for DTS Futsal...

9 hours ago | Sports

After the success of the 2020 Nedbank DTS Futsal Tournament, Nedbank has again sponsored N$100 000 towards the DTS Futsal Development Team this year. The...

Family crushed by court ruling...

21 hours ago | Justice

Windhoek • [email protected] what has been described as a judicial cop out, a Namibian High Court judge on Monday refused to set aside the Ministry...

Ignore the myths and get...

1 day - 18 April 2021 | Health

Deputy Minister of Health and Social Services, Esther Muinjangue, said Namibians should ignore myths around Covid-19 vaccines and get vaccinated. She said this on Friday...

Educate children on their rights...

1 day - 18 April 2021 | Crime

Children’s advocate Ingrid Husselmann said having a good legal framework for child protection is not enough in Namibia and more needs to be done to...

Post-budget event unpacks Namibia's fiscal...

1 day - 18 April 2021 | Business

RMB Namibia held a post-budget event with clients in Windhoek and Swakopmund under the theme 'Unpacking Namibia’s fiscal sustainability trajectory.'Ruusa Nandago, FirstRand Namibia Economist talked...

Women seen in house buying...

1 day - 18 April 2021 | Business

The FNB House Price Index posted an annual growth of 3.5% year on year at the end of 2020 compared to -4.7% y/y recorded over...

Load More