Universal income grant is not realistic now

05 February 2021 | Social Issues

Windhoek • [email protected]

A monthly universal grant of N$500 to citizens aged 19 to 59 amidst a rickety economy and Covid-19’s economic carnage in addition to high levels of spending on non-development items such as VIP protection, state wages and defence acquisitions, makes it an unrealistic wish at this stage.
Economists say that while a universal basic income grant (BIG) is not a bad idea, Namibia simply cannot afford it right now.
“Although such a grant will go a long way to alleviate the hardship faced by many and will also be a great economic stimulus, the time is not now,” economist Omu Kakujaha-Matundu says.
He pointed out that government finances are stretched to the limit, and the uncertainties around the duration of the pandemic and financial pressure to provide health care to citizens “make such a grant wishful thinking”.
“I think despite the economic hardships that the general population faces, we should put the basic income grant on the back-burner and concentrate on defeating the pandemic,” Kakujaha-Matundu noted.
IJG Securities research analyst Dylan van Wyk agreed that “a basic income grant of N$500 per person might be too expensive for the country to afford at this point”. He added that Namibia’s struggling economy and skewed spending focus has drained the coffers to the extent that increased social grants are not a possibility now.
“The annual budget should be viewed as the country’s list of priorities, and I feel that those priorities are not in order. The development budget is being neglected in favour of the public sector wage bill, which will impede economic growth in the long term.”
He added that “similarly VIP protection and defence procurement also take priority over more pressing issues such as housing,” adding that this despite government categorizing informal settlements as a humanitarian disaster.

Helping hand
An online petition, that has attracted close to 1 500 signatures in support, was launched five months ago and has drawn increasing support in recent weeks.
“The Covid-19 pandemic has made things worse for us. It has added to our burden of day-to-day struggle for survival. Many of us have lost our jobs due to the pandemic. Many Namibians are employed in the informal sector on which they desperately depend on as their only source of income,” the authors of the petition write.
BIG advocates argue that this scheme is affordable, if government shifts its current priorities and weeds out widespread corruption.
“It’s time that Namibia’s mining and fishing industries that make billions in profits pay their due share of taxes. Corruption, tax evasion and illicit financial flows result in the loss of billions of much needed income that government could use to finance BIG.”
The petition accuses government of failing to work on their promises to address poverty in Namibia. “Nothing but lip service.”

Costly
Rough calculations done by Van Wyk estimates that the total bill for a N$500 monthly grant could amount to roughly N$9 billion per annum, based on around 1.5 million eligible recipients. If limited to unemployed Namibians, he estimates that would cost taxpayers an estimated N$4 billion a year.
“In other words, this is quite a serious expense that will continue growing and once implemented would be difficult to roll back. A decision like this should be carefully considered.”
He emphasized that he supports a universal income grant, but cautioned that “for a country to afford these grants it needs to be in a fiscal position to be able to afford it, which relies on an efficient and prosperous economy as well as relatively high income tax.”
Van Wyk said that while a monthly income grant is unrealistic for now, “it is not an impossible goal over a ten to 20-year timeframe. This will require an immense amount of public pressure and political will to re-allocate resources.”
Moreover, “funding for this grant will rely on a strong and growing economy, a luxury we do not currently have, but could be achieved following serious reform”.
Kakujaha-Matundu added while there are good policy documents and frameworks that ostensibly address upliftment and poverty eradication, “without inspiring leadership from the top, and no consequences for non-performance, implementation of all those wonderful ideas that could lift thousands out of poverty is just empty talk”.

Game changer
In January 2020 the UN Food and Agriculture Organisation (FAO) reported that “in Namibia, an estimated 430 000 people (18% of the total population) are currently experiencing severe acute food insecurity.”
The report noted that the most affected regions were Hardap, Kavango East, Khomas, Kunene, Ohangwena, Omaheke, Omusati, and Zambezi.
“Despite the ongoing humanitarian interventions provided by the government of Namibia, helping around 258 000 people, 18% of the country’s total population requires immediate humanitarian action.”
A 2008 pilot project at Otjivero and Omitara, where residents were given N$100 per person per month, according to some findings, disputed by some, showed a significant drop in child malnutrition, and reduced household poverty from 76% to 37%; school attendance increased, and there was a reduction in crime. Also, the added income improved access to medical services, and economic activities increased as residents used the funds to start small business.
Melanie Gaoes of the Namibia Rural Women’s Assembly in January told the BIG coalition that if approved, such a grant could be “a big game changer for Namibia at large”. She pointed out that especially women would benefit, and in turn their children, which could stop the vicious cycle of poverty many are trapped in now.
The BIG coalition website argues that a basic income grant for all Namibians in the specific age bracket will not only reduce poverty and inequality, but would redistribute income from the rich to the poor, “and so would make Namibia a more just and equal society”.
The coalition says such a grant would be possible through adjustments to income tax structures, a VAT increase, and a reprioritisation of the budget.

Similar News

 

Struggle kids ‘stigmatised’

1 hour ago | Social Issues

Children of the liberation struggle, also known as ‘struggle kids’, feel it is hard for them to secure employment outside government, because there is a...

Seeing the future

2 days ago - 20 April 2021 | Social Issues

Tanja Wilckens of Pro-Specs and Marlize Hall of African Eyes Optometrist donated their time to performing eye-screenings on 53 learners of N/a’an ku sê Primary...

Head of UNAIDS meets DREAMS girls

1 week ago - 15 April 2021 | Social Issues

The executive director of the Joint United Nations Program on HIV and AIDS (UNAIDS), Winnie Byanyima, recently visited beneficiaries of the US-funded DREAMS project in...

Small increase for GIPF pensioners

1 week ago - 14 April 2021 | Social Issues

The Government Institutions Pension Fund (GIPF) announced a 3% pension benefit increase, effective 1 April 2021 for all GIPF pensioners.In a media release, the GIPF...

In love with Dairy Love

3 weeks ago - 01 April 2021 | Social Issues

Namibia Media Holdings’ staff recently collected funds with support of Namibia Dairy’s latest product, Dairy Love, to donate to the Cancer Association of Namibia (CAN)....

Taking hands with MealForTwo

4 weeks ago - 24 March 2021 | Social Issues

Food security in Namibia remains a big concern and the need for assistance is increasing as more families find themselves in a desperate situation brought...

Changemakers celebrate Independence at Groot Aub

4 weeks ago - 23 March 2021 | Social Issues

In the spirit of Independence celebrations, Capricorn Group employees in their role as Changemakers, visited the community of Groot Aub to bring joy to the...

‘Stop handouts for street kids’

4 weeks ago - 23 March 2021 | Social Issues

The Ministry of Gender Equality, Poverty Eradication and Social Welfare has acquired a farm in the Witvlei area that will be used as a drug...

Two informal settlements on verge of Open Defecation Free...

1 month - 16 March 2021 | Social Issues

Windhoek • [email protected] communities at the outskirts of Windhoek are anxiously waiting to hear if they have achieved open defecation free (ODF) status, a possible...

Law seeks to make it easier to say ‘I...

1 month - 16 March 2021 | Social Issues

Windhoek • [email protected] steep financial and emotional costs involved in obtaining a divorce in Namibia could be eased greatly if a proposed amended divorce bill...

Latest News

Struggle kids ‘stigmatised’

1 hour ago | Social Issues

Children of the liberation struggle, also known as ‘struggle kids’, feel it is hard for them to secure employment outside government, because there is a...

Central estates agents awarded

1 hour ago | Banking

Aqua Real Estate, Rightmove Properties Windhoek and Arnel Properties were announced as the top three central estate agencies servicing Bank Windhoek.In the category for Residential...

Knight Piésold celebrates a century

2 hours ago | Business

From its humble beginnings in South Africa on 1 April 1921, Knight Piésold has established and grown its local operations within Southern Africa, through its...

Visual arts on a roll!

1 day - 21 April 2021 | Art and Entertainment

The Bank Windhoek Triennial 2020 Awards ceremony and exhibition opening takes place on Thursday (22 April 2021) at 16:00. With 491 submissions received of which...

Family’s battle to reunite continues...

1 day - 21 April 2021 | Justice

Windhoek • [email protected] Namibian High Commission in Pretoria on Tuesday briefly shut the door to Namibian Phillip Lühl after he tried to submit a formal...

Campaigning for counselling

1 day - 21 April 2021 | Crime

Members of Parliament (MPs) have proposed compulsory counselling and psychological support for victims, perpetrators or anyone exposed to gender-based violence to end the cycle of...

Whistleblower Stefánsson scoops WIN WIN...

1 day - 21 April 2021 | Justice

This year’s winner of the WIN WIN Gothenburg Sustainability Award is the Icelandic whistleblower Jóhannes Stefánsson, who led the revelation of a widespread corruption scandal...

Sewing machines, fabric for NCS

1 day - 21 April 2021 | Business

Mulungushi Textiles & Importers recently donated overlock sewing machines and fabrics worth around N$100 000 to the Namibian Correctional Services. The Khomas & Hardap regions...

Is your agent making use...

1 day - 21 April 2021 | Life Style

The way we live and work has been dramatically altered by the pandemic. It follows then that the way people buy and sell houses will...

Load More