Where to with the animals?

Was the killing of hyenas in the Garub the right decision to protect the Wild Horses? Was this deed morally defendable? And is this actually the right way to protect the horses in the long term? Various experts met to discuss these and other issues.

10 March 2019 | Environment

Windhoek • Nina Cerezo



Following the recent culling of hyenas to save the Wild Horses of the Garub, environment minister Pohamba Shifeta repeatedly referred to the act as a “short-term solution” aimed at “winning some time for the horses”. After all, the Wild Horse Management Plan is still in a development phase, which will eventually safeguard the long-term existence of the horses.

Until then though, “we will fight by any means to ensure that every foal survives from now on,” he said.

Shifeta made this statement at a panel discussion held by the Scientific Society in the capital last week.

Various stakeholders were in attendance, some questioning the action taken by the ministry on several levels.

One example is Ruben Portas of the Namibian Environment and Wildlife Society (NEWS), who is campaigning for the peaceful coexistence between wild animals and is against human intervention. “What is the purpose of a national park when animals are killed there? Is this consistent with what these protected areas are intended to serve?” he wanted to know.

In the same vein, the managing director of the Namibian Chamber of Environmental Dr Chris Brown, said that spotted hyenas are just as endangered as the horses. He explained that these animals can only survive in protected areas and not on farmland at all.

“In Namibia, there are only between 500 and 600 of these animals [hyenas] left,” Brown said, adding that their chances of survival following a relocation are “extremely unlikely” since they would either be expelled or attacked. “If we do this, we're just shifting the problem,” Brown said.



Relocating horses?

Thus, both Portas and Brown are of the opinion that relocating the hyenas will not accomplish the desired goal. “So it's the horses that need to find a new home,” Brown opined.

He even spoke of the “extreme cruelty” of keeping hoofed animals – which can hardly be described as wild– in such a dry area “just for the benefit of a few people living there”. The most rain this area receives on average in March, is just 15 mm, Brown said.

Mannfred Goldbeck, chairman of the Wild Horses Foundation, also feels the resettlement of horses would deliver the desired solution. In actual fact, he said that just a few years ago this plan was the intention given that a farmer near Aus agreed to take the animals. “But the horses belong to the state and we have not received the go-ahead from the line ministry,” he said.

Goldbeck therefore requested that the minister rethink the idea of the often-requested and repeatedly rejected “guardianship” programme for the animals.

Shifeta, however, expressed his doubt about this concept, which is also used for the protection of black rhinos. “People don't stick to the agreements,” Shifeta said, and pointed out that the killing of “problem animals” under certain conditions is “legal”.



Tourism value

Moreover, the minister considers the resettlement of horses as inappropriate because their current location contributes significantly to the ­tourism sector of nearby communities. “And we cannot ignore these communities in the solution,” Shifeta said.

Goldbeck agreed with this point, saying these are the only horses in the world that have survived in a desert and that there is already a considerable relationship between tourism and the horses.

Brown has a different opinion: “I do not know anybody travelling to Namibia just because of the Wild Horses, so we would not lose any visitors,” he said. “They are of little value to tourism.”

Similar News

 

From cooking oil to biofuel

2 weeks ago - 10 March 2019 | Environment

Windhoek • Yolanda NelA bottle of cooking oil is heated up in the deep fryer to make the perfect, golden chicken nuggets. Once the oil...

How the Moringa can purify water

2 weeks ago - 10 March 2019 | Environment

Next Thursday (14 March), the National Commission on Research, Science & Technology (NCRST) hosts a public lecture presented by Prof Habauka Kwaambwa on the evaluation...

Climate change slows aquaculture

3 weeks ago - 03 March 2019 | Environment

Lüderitz • Ewin LeuschnerA workshop titled Enhancing Climate Change Resilience in the Benguela Current Fisheries System was ­held in Lüderitz recently, where experts discussed the...

Blue economy faces myriad challenges

3 weeks ago - 03 March 2019 | Environment

Windhoek • Jana-Mari Smith “The work on Namibia's blue economy is on-going, yet little information on the status thereof exists,” says Institute for Public Policy...

Way too much waste in Africa

4 weeks ago - 24 February 2019 | Environment

Windhoek • Yolanda Nel Current trends indicate that Africa's waste generation is expected to reach more than 240 million tonnes per year by 2025...

Conservation snapshot

1 month - 17 February 2019 | Environment

On Tuesday (19 February), Peter Bridgeford launches the book Conservation Pioneers in Namibia and stories by Game Rangers at the Scientific Society.This book of personal...

Elke bietjie help

1 month - 10 February 2019 | Environment

Yolanda Nel Daar is niks so lekker soos ’n heerlike espresso nie – veral nie as daardie varsgemaalde goue stroop deur ’n masjien loop nie.En...

Insects heading to Windhoek soon

1 month - 04 February 2019 | Environment

Yolanda Nel With large areas of the capital already infested by three invasive cactus species, various avenues are being pursued to prevent further spread...

Get your green fingers going

1 month - 27 January 2019 | Environment

Ever wanted to grow your own veg? Then don't miss out on seedling production training taking place in the capital next month.This hands on training...

Kniediep in die gemors

1 month - 27 January 2019 | Environment

Yolanda Nel - Inwoners van die Hakahana informele nedersetting in die hoofstad is moeg dat versoeke aan die Windhoekse stadsraad om rommel te verwyder, op...

Latest News

Beach volleyball action at the...

1 hour ago | Sports

Social division action from the first day of the Namibian Volley Ball Federation (NVB) organised 2019 Bank Windhoek Swakopmund Beach Volleyball tournament at the Mole....

Schools compete at desert sport...

1 hour ago | Sports

The sixth annual Buco Desert Sport Festival took place from 19 to 23 March at the Walvis Bay Private High School sports field. This year...

Bullseye

1 hour ago | Sports

Thirty eight archers are competing at the first ever outdoor target archery competition in Swakopmund. The competition which is taking place over two days...

The soldiers among us

1 hour ago | Sports

Windhoek • Yolanda NelHundreds of athletes and rookies joined in the fun during the Toyota Warrior Race that took place at Heja Lodge yesterday. Armin...

Two in a row for...

1 hour ago | Sports

Swakopmund • Adolf KaureThe second edition of the Sanlam Coastal Marathon took place in Swakopmund.Mynhard Kauanivi won the men's 42.2 km marathon for the second...

Fundraising for strays

1 day - 24 March 2019 | Society

Windhoek • Yolanda NelGiven that a single pair of dogs and their offspring are able to produce more than 11 000 puppies a year and...

Kom bak en brou saam

1 day - 24 March 2019 | Society

Windhoek • Yolanda NelWou jy nog altyd ook koekies mooi versier, maar die taak lyk glad nie bereikbaar nie?Dan is hierdie ’n geleentheid wat jy...

Little foot entertains

1 day - 24 March 2019 | Business

A newly erected chameleon structure is entertaining children at the Grove Mall of Namibia.Since chameleons are well-known for their adaptations to survive the brutal deserts,...

A better future for the...

1 day - 24 March 2019 | Social Issues

Windhoek • Yolanda NelStatistics on how many Namibian children are at risk, is dire. As a result, a group of people decided that something needs...

Load More